2
0
mirror of https://github.com/xcat2/xcat-core.git synced 2026-11-20 17:32:15 +00:00
Daniel Hilst 4ee82d40d8 fix(xcat-core): a stateless node is told to run SELinux and cannot boot
netboot_supported() answered 1 for rhels8 and later and for every
openEuler, so mknetboot wrote no selinux= argument and a stateless node
was asked to run SELinux enforcing. It does not boot.

A stateless root is a cpio archive unpacked into tmpfs, and cpio carries
no SELinux label, so the root starts unlabelled. Three boots of an
AlmaLinux 10.1 image on an enforcing node measured both ways out of
that, on cluster xcat163:

- With the stock dracut selinux module, which this branch added to the
  module list, the policy loads at pre-pivot 50 over the unlabelled
  initramfs. 61 Permission denied lines follow, setfiles returns 126 and
  the node loops. That module ships with check() returning 255, so no
  image enables it by accident.
- Without it, and with the relabel hook corrected, setfiles labels the
  root: /usr/lib/systemd/systemd reads init_exec_t. systemd then loads
  the policy after switch_root, cannot relabel /dev or /run, and stops
  with "Failed to allocate manager object. Freezing execution".

The hook could not have worked as written either. It read the mode with
sed piped into tail, and the initramfs has neither tail nor chroot:
chroot arrived with the selinux module. The console reported "tail:
command not found" twice and relabelled nothing.

So netboot_supported() answers 0, mknetboot writes selinux=0 for every
stateless node and nodeset says why. The code that only serves a
stateless node with SELinux on is removed with it: the relabel hook and
its two installers, the selinux dracut module, write_image_config, and
the squashfs label machinery that stored labels nothing reads. The
netboot postinstalls and the stateless xcatroot write SELINUX=disabled
again, so the image says what the kernel command line does.

What stays is what was measured working: a diskful node provisioned
enforcing with zero xCAT denials, the kickstart templates, the policy
package, and the service node mount options.

Tests: selinux_netboot_kcmdline.t fails 34 of its 69 checks on the
parent commit. selinux_cn_diskless_disabled_by_design in cases1
provisions a stateless node asked for enforcing and requires selinux=0
on its command line and getenforce Disabled. selinux_image_config.t and
selinux_squashfs_labels.t go with the subs they tested.

Signed-off-by: Daniel Hilst <392820+dhilst@users.noreply.github.com>
2026-10-21 10:35:22 -03:00
2024-05-07 16:43:07 +02:00
2018-11-28 10:28:17 +08:00
2021-04-05 09:34:37 -04:00
2018-02-09 01:03:46 -05:00
2024-04-20 02:18:05 +02:00
2026-04-17 03:14:04 -03:00

xCAT

xCAT is a toolkit for deployment and administration of clusters of all sizes.

The xCAT sunset was only a quick eclipse

Dear xCAT Community,

The xCAT sunset has changed course. VersatusHPC has been invited to join the xCAT Consortium, and future development will move toward direct upstream contributions coordinated with the Consortium and its existing member companies.

That matters most for Enterprise Linux 10 (EL10). EL10 support is coming to xCAT, restoring a future operating-system path for sites that still rely on xCAT. This is an important change from the previous sunset guidance, where the lack of an EL10 path was one of the strongest reasons to move away from xCAT.

The xCAT Consortium continues to recommend Confluent as the long-term successor to xCAT, and that remains the Consortium position. Users planning new cluster-management deployments should evaluate Confluent and its xCAT comparison documentation.

At the same time, xCAT is no longer sunsetted. The Consortium and participating companies will continue updating xCAT while there is community and user demand for it.

In summary:

  • xCAT development is continuing upstream through the Consortium and participating companies.
  • Enterprise Linux 10 support is coming.
  • Confluent remains the Consortium-recommended successor and migration path.
  • xCAT updates will continue while there is community and user demand.

We want to thank the xCAT Consortium and community for keeping this project moving. The sun went behind the moon for a moment, but xCAT is still here.

For more information on Confluent and how to get started, please visit the Confluent: Project Page, Documentation or Confluent vs xCAT comparison.

With thanks,

The xCAT Consortium

Documentation

xCAT Documentation is hosted on Read The Docs: https://xcat-docs.readthedocs.io

Status

xCAT Version Build Status
Latest (master branch) Documentation Status
Stable (latest release) Documentation Status

Looking for older versions?

Open Source License

xCAT is made available under the EPL license: https://opensource.org/licenses/eclipse-1.0.php

Developers

Want to help? Check out the developers guide!

S
Description
No description provided
Readme EPL-1.0 238 MiB
Languages
Perl 75.9%
Shell 13.1%
JavaScript 5.2%
Python 2.3%
Go Template 2.1%
Other 0.9%